R 1200 GS/GSA : Charcoal Cannister Removal

drmajor

Too Many Roads, Too Little Time

Posts: 61

Motorbike: 255

Location: Charleston, SC

Thanks: 13

Sunday, August 10th 2008, 8:04pm

Charcoal Cannister Removal

Cannister- 2007 Remove and now Rough Idle

Just took the Cannister off to make room for Ohlins.

Went for a ride this evening and the idle is VERY rough- like it wants to shut down. Idle is about 1100. It also seems to "back-fire" POP a little more when I shut the throttle down.

Seems to run fine above idle.

I followed the steps posted on here to plug the two 1/4" ports and the vacuum port on the left TB. I extended the "breather" hose back down under the frame with a 3/16" hose which fits the hose coming from the front.

I don't think the tank is sucking to vacuum and we rode about 25 miles, so I think my vent line is open..

Do I need to rebalance the TB?????

I am pretty sure I don't have an air leak..?

David Major
Charleston, SC
'02 GSA, '03 LT

Peter

Candyman

Posts: 1,053

Motorbike: R1200GS-07

Mileage: 47,000 km

Location: Singapore

Thanks: 1184

Wednesday, August 20th 2008, 3:42pm

David, I was hoping someone else would jump in, someone who may have encountered the same problem.

I removed the canister just the same method on mine. I do not have any issue, and I can not imagine how the removal would have the effects you are describing - unless your work created a vacuum leak somewhere, e.g. plugging a port.

Peter .PEOPLE WHO HAVE VISIONS SHOULD GO TO SEE THEIR DOCTOR

drmajor

Too Many Roads, Too Little Time

Posts: 61

Motorbike: 255

Location: Charleston, SC

Thanks: 13

Friday, August 22nd 2008, 7:19pm

Cannister removal- my dummy

Well I found the issue....dumb.

I had left the "stopper" off the vacuum connector on the right TB. DUMB

David Major
Charleston, SC
'02 GSA, '03 LT

1 registered user thanked already.

Users who thanked for this post:

Peter

Candyman

Posts: 1,053

Motorbike: R1200GS-07

Mileage: 47,000 km

Location: Singapore

Thanks: 1184

Friday, August 22nd 2008, 9:24pm

Great you found it, and thanks for feed-back!

Peter .PEOPLE WHO HAVE VISIONS SHOULD GO TO SEE THEIR DOCTOR

ghostrider1964

Edumacated Redneck Adventurer

Posts: 244

Motorbike: R1200GSA-08 and 01 ATK 605 Enduro

Mileage: 45,000 miles

Location: CORYELL CITY, TEXAS

Thanks: 347

Friday, September 5th 2008, 2:19am

Does removing the cannister void warranty? ?-(

2008 R1200 GSA
2001 ATK 605 Enduro
Many others that are gone 8-)

http://www.rollthebonesrally.com/

Peter

Candyman

Posts: 1,053

Motorbike: R1200GS-07

Mileage: 47,000 km

Location: Singapore

Thanks: 1184

Friday, September 5th 2008, 8:07am

Unless the charcoal cannister removal is the cause of the problem, the warranty is not denied. In principal it functions like this: should the engine die on starvation and there is a non approved air filter, BMW may refer you to the filter maker.

How the absent charcoal cannister could cause a damage, I am not aware of anything. A faulty job done when removing is of course another matter.

Peter .PEOPLE WHO HAVE VISIONS SHOULD GO TO SEE THEIR DOCTOR

ghostrider1964

Edumacated Redneck Adventurer

Posts: 244

Motorbike: R1200GSA-08 and 01 ATK 605 Enduro

Mileage: 45,000 miles

Location: CORYELL CITY, TEXAS

Thanks: 347

Saturday, September 13th 2008, 4:19am

I went looking for my canister,does the 08 American bikes have the canister? ?-(

2008 R1200 GSA
2001 ATK 605 Enduro
Many others that are gone 8-)

http://www.rollthebonesrally.com/

ghostrider1964

Edumacated Redneck Adventurer

Posts: 244

Motorbike: R1200GSA-08 and 01 ATK 605 Enduro

Mileage: 45,000 miles

Location: CORYELL CITY, TEXAS

Thanks: 347

Saturday, January 10th 2009, 5:51am

Come on now!!! does the 08s have the cannister? :evil:

2008 R1200 GSA
2001 ATK 605 Enduro
Many others that are gone 8-)

http://www.rollthebonesrally.com/

Peter

Candyman

Posts: 1,053

Motorbike: R1200GS-07

Mileage: 47,000 km

Location: Singapore

Thanks: 1184

Saturday, January 10th 2009, 11:42am

The '08 tank has a separate compartment on the right side, which accommodates the evaporation canister. If the US models have one, I don't know. (Nice free space if you don't have one!)

photo source: member Che-Q-Vara at http://www.gs-forum.eu

My '07 had one, it is the Californistan model.

Peter .PEOPLE WHO HAVE VISIONS SHOULD GO TO SEE THEIR DOCTOR

ghostrider1964

Edumacated Redneck Adventurer

Posts: 244

Motorbike: R1200GSA-08 and 01 ATK 605 Enduro

Mileage: 45,000 miles

Location: CORYELL CITY, TEXAS

Thanks: 347

Thursday, January 15th 2009, 1:35am

Unless my glasses are missleading it does not apear to have Charcoal cannister, at least not where it was on 07s...gonna check further...

2008 R1200 GSA
2001 ATK 605 Enduro
Many others that are gone 8-)

http://www.rollthebonesrally.com/

Boston12GS

Posts: 1

Motorbike: '08 R1200GSA

Location: Boston, MA, USA/Maastricht, Netherlands

Thanks: 1

Saturday, May 29th 2010, 11:37pm

Peter has it right, the charcoal canister on the '08 is located on the inner face of the right-hand fuel lobe, as indicated in his photograph (which shows the space usually occupied by the canister--obviously in his case the canister has been removed. And it can be a very useful space, it's where the compressor for my Stebel horn resides on my '08GSA.

By the way, in Peter's photo you can see two threaded inserts in the tank, one on each side of the cubby. These are very useful for holding in place anything you install in the cubby, but be VERY careful in tightening on these, the inserts will spin VERY easily in the fuel lobe.

I previously posted a detailed thread on removing the charcoal canister and installing a Stebel horn on my '08 GSA on the advrider site, at: http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?t=386336

Quoted from "ghostrider1964"

Unless my glasses are missleading it does not apear to have Charcoal cannister, at least not where it was on 07s...gonna check further...